|
The following e-mail was recently sent to William Edelen Ministries. William Edelen is an ordained "minister" who preaches New Age ideas and publicly speaks out against the Bible. To date, he has not bothered to respond to our questions.
Dear Pastor Edelen,
According to your biography at William Edelen Ministries your list of accomplishments include:
- Lecturer of religion and anthropology
- In 1990, received a grant from the Annenberg Foundation to promote religious literacy through writing and speaking
- Entered McCormick Theological Seminary (on the campus of the University of Chicago) and received a Masters degree in Theology
- Special studies with Joseph Campbell, whom the New York Times called "The pre-eminent scholar in Comparative Religions and Mythology"
- Active ordained Presbyterian and Congregational minister, 30 years
Impressive credentials. Too bad you're not using them for God!
Pastor Edelen, we are writing to you on behalf of God and the Bible, which you seem to be slaughtering at every turn. According to one of your websites, you are an "active, ordained Presbyterian minister". However, judging by the blasphemous garbage espoused in many of your articles, you can't possibly be a minister of God because a true minister preaches from the Word, not from the world. Why do you claim the title of "minister" if you can't follow God's Word? If you don't believe in God and think that the Bible is a book of fiction, then why did you choose the profession of pastor? Why are you using God's Name in vain by blaspheming Him and the Bible at every turn? According to some of your articles, you believe that most of what we read about Yeshua (Jesus' given Hebrew name) didn't happen and that the Gospels are fiction. You've even written articles for the Freethinkers of Colorado Springs from a New Age perspective!
Let's face it: What you are really doing is making money off your title as pastor by presenting "ear-tickling" doctrine to a lost world that is itching to hear negative comments about God and the Bible. You are obviously one of the "false prophets" the Bible warns us about (Matthew 24:4-14) and you need to be exposed.
Let's examine some of your writings.
For the Colorado Springs Freethinkers in an article entitled, Earthrise you wrote:
|
"We are one with the Earth and we are one with the furthest star in the furthest galaxy"....
"Millions today are moving away from the dead forms, symbols and dogmas of religious orthodoxy to the beauty and revelation of direct experience. Out of the tombs of religious establishments, this resurrection movement begins with reaffirmation of the Earth as a living, breathing entity.
"Mother Earth, Gaia, the sacred Goddess, the Greeks called her. Maka Wakan, the sacred Earth, the American Sioux named her. From the soil of this basic premise will flower the birth of a new consciousness that includes everything that is part of this sacred Goddess: every four- and two-legged animal...every winged one of the sky and fish of the sea...every grass and flower...every grain of sand and drop of water...every rock, mineral and crystal…all are as ONE and offer thanks-giving to our great Mother Goddess Earth for her support and sustenance. A new consciousness, not any theological "belief," is at the heart of this resurrection of spirituality".....
"EARTHRISE...this great Goddess Earth...rising above the horizon of the moon...can be a brilliant and glorious symbol of a new consciousness...in this month of April where we set aside a special day to celebrate our mother and our home...this sacred Earth. Where the Great Goddess of nature creates and makes all things new.".....
|
New Age garbage that has nothing, whatsoever to do with your title as pastor, or your degree in Theology! We CHALLENGE you to find the Scriptures to support the "Mother Earth" hogwash. And then we challenge you to drop your title as pastor because you don't deserve it. You don't speak for God or the Bible.
At Edelen you wrote this biblically unsound opinion piece:
|
William Edelen, November 30, 2003
Behind every gun in the mideast bloodbath is a religious scripture. Jew and Muslims are slaughtering each other over religion. They are butchering each other over their claim that this is "sacred" ground for their religious tradition. Both are claiming that "God" gave it to them. It is religion that feeds and fuels the violence and the slaughtering of other human beings, and all being done in "Gods" name.
If I hear one more empty airhead use the stupid cliche that "without religion there would be no morality", I think I'll throw up. The fact is this: religion is the direct cause of immorality and amorality. Without religion this earth would be a far, far more peaceful place with far more harmony between cultures and people. Every war going on today on this earth has religion as the fuel keeping it alive.
Protestants and Catholics are slaughtering each other in Ireland. The Catholic Croats and Orthodox Christian Serbs slaughtered each other while both slaughtered the Bosnian Muslims. Hindus slaughter Muslims and Sikhs slaughter Hindus in India. In Pakistan Sunni Muslims and Shite Muslims slaughter each other Crusaders for God hack to death thousands in Algeria and cut off their heads. Christianity spread across Europe in the Crusades and Inquisitions and butchered or burned Muslims, Jews and Protestants. Christian missionaries swarmed down on the New World and brutalized all native peoples bringing with them violent Christianity topped off with all the other diseases of white men.
I don't know how many times I have heard some featherhead jabber about those "horrible atheists, Stalin and Hitler and the killing they did. " Hitler was no atheist, but what a joke. Hitler and Stalin were pikers, second stringers in killing, compared to those who have "killed for God".
If you start adding up the religious killing "for God" over the past 3000 years, starting with the slaughtering of nomadic people as recorded in the Old Testament by Moses and others, then you count your way through the slaughtering of Meso Americans, Aztecs, Incas and Mayas by Christian zealots; then count your way through the astronomical figures given by historians of those slaughtered in the Crusades and Inquisitions (over eight million "witches" alone) then pick up the count today in 2003 of all the killing going on around the world in the "name of God". Well, as you can plainly see, Hitler and Stalin were pikers compared to "killers for God".
"Without religion there would be no morality" many blabber about. What brainless drivel.
Behind every gun today in the bloodbath of the Mideast is a religious scripture...and the Jews say "this is our sacred ground" and the Muslims say "this is our sacred ground"...and both tell the other "God gave it to us, not you...and we are going to kill you to prove it...kill you in the name of our "God:".
As long as they both have 'religion'...there will never be peace.
|
The only "brainless drivel" is what you have written above! God gave us His Torah (first five books of Moses) as a blueprint for behavior. Without it, man would still be drowning in the quagmire of paganism.
The bottom line about the trouble in the Middle East IS that it's rooted in the jealousy between Isaac and Ishmael. It will not be resolved until Yeshua returns. In the meantime, EVERYTHING hinges on Israel and the Jews.
And there's nothing your "Mother Earth" and "consciousness" can do to change those facts.
In your article 1999 article, The Sin of Silence, you wrote:
|
There is a sin among a large segment of the Christian clergy that I find despicable. It is the sin of omission, the sin of silence. It is the sin of promoting falsehoods in order to hold your job. It is the sin of not sharing with a congregation what you know to be true about the bible and Christianity.
|
NOTE FROM THE REFINER'S FIRE: Are you proposing what you are offering the world isn't a sin? Is it not a sin to tell lies about God and the Bible while posing as a man of God? What you are "sharing with your congregations" every time you open your mouth or set pen to paper is certainly not "truth about the Bible"!
|
Those graduating in religious studies from every major university in America, as well as every major theological seminary that is independent of Christian financial pressure, know certain facts to be true.
They know that:
- The entire bible is saturated with common mythological themes, from the creation and flood myth to virgin birth and resurrected hero mythology
- The stories of the patriarchs in the Old Testament are known as 'temple legends' to enhance the history of the Hebrew people and are mostly fictional.
- The gospels were not written by anyone who knew Jesus personally.
- The 'Christ' myths and formulas are direct copies of Zoroastrian myths adopted by the Jesus sect.
- These facts, with others, have been known for years, and taught by internationally respected scholars from major universities world wide.
Religiously educated clergy, through the sin of omission and silence, yet continue to promote superstition.
|
NOTE FROM THE REFINER'S FIRE: Is that really what graduates of religious institutions know? Have you taken a scientific poll to verify those ridiculous allegations? Who are the "respected scholars" - are they supposed "men of God" like you? We challenge you to PROVE everyone of the above allegations!
And while you're at it, explain away the over 300 Bible prophecies that have thus far been fulfilled - most of them by Yeshua: Accurate Messiah Prophecies. Explain how He has so far fulfilled four of the seven Biblical feasts - with the next one being "the rapture". If He fulfilled the first four, what makes you think He won't fulfill the last three?
Explain why the Bible (specifically the Books of Daniel and Revelation) is literally unfolding before our very eyes in these end times. Read Endtime Questions and Signs of Christ's Return.
|
I lost count of the ministerial colleagues, in both the Presbyterian and Congregational churches, who said to me: "For God's sake, Edelen... forget what you learned in seminary ... just play the game ... you get big churches that way."
|
NOTE FROM THE REFINER'S FIRE: Well, you're certainly doing that!
|
...For those who know better and yet have chosen, through the sin of omission and silence, to promote falsehoods, I chose the word 'despicable' to define them.
|
NOTE FROM THE REFINER'S FIRE: And how would you define yourself? Can you really look into the mirror every morning and not feel the least bit guilty that you are deceiving both God AND the world?
It's not surprising that your thinking has been skewed - after all you are a Presbyterian minister, and Presbyterians aren't exactly "on the mark" when it comes to the Bible. We've challenged them, as well! See Presbyterians Praise Muslims and Reader responds.
Looking forward to your response!
Biblical Truth @ The Refiner's Fire (therefinersfire.org)
An international network of Hebraic Faith teachers offering no-nonsense Biblical answers.
America ~ Brazil ~ United Kingdom ~ Kenya
|